Firm Logo


Michelle Lodzinski Found Guilty of Murdering Her Child in New Jersey 25 Years Ago

May 20, 2016

Michelle Lodzinski Found Guilty of Murdering Her Child in New Jersey 25 Years Ago

A Middlesex County jury recently convicted Michelle Lodzinski on charges of murdering her five-year-old son more than two decades ago.

The verdict was handed down by a jury of seven men and five women after a lengthy trial in Middlesex County Superior Court in New Brunswick, NJ.

Lodzinski, a 48-year-old Florida woman who lived in South Amboy NJ when the homicide occurred, cried after the jury said that she was guilty of first-degree murder.

Timothy Wiltsey, Lodzinski’s son, went missing on May 25, 1991. During the subsequent investigation, Lodzinski told law enforcement that her son had disappeared while attending a local carnival in Sayreville, New Jersey. However, police became suspicious when Lodzinski began to change her story.

At one point, Lodzinski said that her son had not simply disappeared but rather that he had been kidnapped from the carnival. Despite Lodzinki’s claims that someone kidnapped her child, no one at the carnival was able to report having seen Wiltsey on the carnival grounds.

Approximately one year after Wiltsey disappeared, local police discovered his remains buried in the Edison NJ marshlands.

Lodzinski was not actually charged with murder until 2014, when investigators caught a break as witnesses came forward to connect Wiltsey to a blanket that was found near his remains.

The recent murder trial lasted eight weeks, with Middlesex County prosecutors arguing that Lodzinski killed her son because she was struggling to raise him and believed that her life would be made easier by his death.

Now Lodzinski is set to be sentenced after the jury found her guilty on the most serious criminal charges of homicide.

Lodzinski’s defense lawyer said that his client plans to appeal the murder conviction.

In the meantime, Lodzinski will have to return to Middlesex County Superior Court on August 23 so that she can be formally sentenced. It is possible that she could end up spending the rest of her life in NJ State Prison.

For additional information about this case, read the article, “Woman Convicted of Killing 5-Year-Old Son in 1991.”

If you or a loved one has been arrested for murder, aggravated assault or any other violent crime in New Jersey or Pennsylvania, you should speak with a qualified criminal defense attorney as soon as possible. The experienced criminal defense lawyers at Garber Law, P.C. will help you contest your charges and avoid the most severe penalties. Contact us now to schedule a free consultation about your case.

Garber Law, P.C. Has Achieved Numerous

Multi-Million Dollar Results

Get The Compensation You Deserve!

Settlements and verdicts may vary and are based on the many factors of your case, etc.
(The below information may not apply to your settlement and verdict).

$10 Million Dollars

Settlement During Trial for a Leg Amputation











  • Quote

    Mr. Garber is amazing! He walked me through my lawsuit every step of the way and answered all of my questions. Not only is he a great lawyer, but he was very caring about my feelings and health throughout the whole process. Thank you, Mr. Garber, for everything you’ve done for me, especially for winning my case!

    Kim C.

  • Working with the firm was my best decision. They were extremely helpful and knowledgeable and definitely worked hard for their clients. I would highly recommend them.

    Linda S.

  • Quote

    Mr. Garber is simply the best. Very knowledgeable, honest, and helpful throughout the whole process. He has been practicing law for many years and is a true professional in the courtroom. Joel Wayne Garber will fight hard for what you deserve.

    Joseph P.

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Provide the information below or call us at:


100% Secure. We respect your privacy. See here.

© 2024 Garber Law, P.C. All Rights Reserved.Disclaimer.Site Map.